| Name | Year |
| Roxanne Didier Nicholas | 2011 |
| Louise Victor | 2010 |
| Iva Satney | 2009 |
| Cathy Daniel | 2008 |
| Soriah John | 2007 |
| Sannyu James | 2006 |
| Joyanne Biscette | 2005 |
| Candy Nicholas | 2004 |
| Shirnaya Stephen | 2003 |
| Tenneil Thomas | 2002 |
| Christelle Macelline | 2001 |
| Anesta Richards | 2000 |
| Patrika Evans | 1999 |
| Kim D’Auvergne | 1998 |
| Solange Stanisclaus | 1997 |
| Joanne Delima | 1996 |
| No Pageant | 1995 |
| No Pageant | 1994 |
| Carinta Cenac | 1993 |
| Marilyn Wilkie | 1992 |
| Mertyl Gjadhar | 1991 |
| Joanna Salton | 1990 |
| Jaquealine Deterville | 1989 |
| Zorida Noville | 1988 |
| Marcia Tyson | 1987 |
| Ava Alexander | 1986 |
| Cleopatra Hall | 1985 |
| Erene Charlemange | 1984 |
| Judy Edwards | 1983 |
| Andrea Deterville | 1982 |
| Lydia Lubin | 1981 |
| Digna St. Omer | 1980 |
| Edel Alexander | 1979 |
| Sheila Semei (won Miss Caribbean) | 1978 |
| Dawn Theobalds | 1977 |
| Cynthia Elibox | 1976 |
| Sophia St Omer (Represented Saint Lucia at Miss World) | 1975 |
| Ann Simon (won Miss Caribbean) | 1974 |
| Pat Joseph (won Miss Caribbean) | 1973 |
| Sybil Deligny | 1972 |
| Andre Skeete | 1971 |
| Kate Jn. Baptiste | 1970 |
| Allison Alleyne (won MissCaribbean) | 1969 |
| Delores Mendes | 1968 |
| Heather York (won Miss Caribbean) | 1967 |
| Jessica Lloyd | 1966 |
| Brenda James | 1965 |
| Yvonne Clauzel | 1964 |
| Jennifer Carasco | 1963 |
| Dianna Lewis | 1962 |
| Marylin Ishmel | 1961 |
| Sheila Clarke | 1960 |
| Alice St. Juste | 1959 |
| Yolande Devaux | 1958 |
| Pat Levexier | 1957 |
| Gene Auguste | 1956 |
| Joycelyn Samuel | 1955 |
| Estella Newton | 1954 |
| Leota Theodore | 1953 |
| Andkia Plummer | 1952 |
| Yolande Clauzel | 1951 |
| Norma Beaubrun | 1950 |
